Planned Ignoring is Still Neglect
Planning to do it in advance does not make it evidence-based or helpful
Planned ignoring
Planned ignoring is intentionally disregarding another person’s feelings and experience. It is unkind, invalidating, and harmful to the relationship.
This is very different from taking a moment to let emotions cool. Using regulation strategies and giving each other time before returning with cooler heads can be highly effective without being dismissive.
Ignoring, on the other hand, conveys lack of concern for someone’s feelings simply because we do not like their behaviour. This is problematic for many reasons.
Firstly, this assumes the acting out is intentional and attention-seeking. So-called “misbehaviour” is really stress behaviour, and is a sign the person is lacking skills or capacity needed for that particular situation.
When someone’s behaviour is maladaptive or harmful, it is communicating something: usually that they feel scared, unhappy, anxious, or uncomfortable.
“The behaviour is just the signal… If caregivers are focused only on modifying behaviour, then all they’re modifying is the signal. But they’re not solving any of the problems that are causing the signal.” — Dr. Ross Greene
Ignoring someone’s behaviour is ignoring their efforts to seek help and support.
Some proponents claim they’re not ignoring the person or their needs, they’re simply ignoring the behaviour, as if we can somehow physically separate the two. A person’s emotions and their behaviour are inextricably linked.
Ignoring a person sends the message that they are on their own with their intense and overwhelming feelings, they will not receive the support they need, and instead are being rejected by the people they rely on to feel safe and secure.
“When we are ignored as human beings, it decreases our emotional links to other people, who should be our life rafts when we are suffering.” — Dr. Mona Delahooke
False dichotomy
“We can’t just give in and enable their behaviour!” they say.
I am not sure how we conflated providing support and compassion with condoning harmful behaviour, but we need to back up and think this through using a critical lens.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Neurodiversity MB to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.